Preparedness
Terrifying Dispute Escalates Into Violent Carjacking Nightmare
In a chilling incident that underscores the unpredictability of everyday interactions, a New York woman found herself in a terrifying situation that escalated over a mere 10 cents. The ordeal, described by the victim as “a ride from hell,” involved carjacking, kidnapping, and a brutal assault, leaving her with physical and emotional scars.
Allison Smith, 29, recounted the events of September 13, which began innocently enough at the Four Guys deli in Rochester. As she was checking out, a woman offered to pay for her purchase with a five-dollar bill. Smith only needed 10 cents and returned $4.90 to the woman, promising to retrieve a dollar from her car to settle the difference.
“I said, ‘No problem, I’m going to go across the street and grab it from my car, then I don’t want any issues,'” Smith explained. However, this attempt to resolve the situation peacefully took a dark turn.
The woman, along with a male accomplice, threatened Smith with a firearm and forced their way into her vehicle. They compelled her to drive around the city, even stopping to pick up another woman they referred to as “wifey.” During this harrowing ride, Smith endured a vicious assault. At one point, a broken pipe was shoved into her mouth, causing severe injuries.
“She’s holding down my head as she’s just repeatedly beating me and telling me I’m going to die tonight,” Smith vividly recalled of the relentless attack.
In a desperate bid for survival, Smith seized an opportunity to fight back. “Whoever’s arm is on me, I bite down as hard as I could, and there was a small release,” she said. “And then I ducked and just ran.” Her escape led her to a nearby convenience store, where a bystander called the police.
The following day, Rochester Police Captain Greg Bello reported that someone driving Smith’s stolen car led authorities on a high-speed chase, which ended when the vehicle hit a curb. Although several individuals fled the scene, police managed to apprehend one suspect. Shawntae Hall, 20, was arrested and faced charges including assault, robbery, unlawful imprisonment, and grand larceny. However, after being released, Hall failed to appear in court, prompting a warrant for her arrest.
Smith’s father, Shane Smith, expressed his anguish upon seeing his daughter in the emergency room, noting that she was “unrecognizable” due to the severity of her injuries. “I want to see people protected,” he urged. “I mean, this could happen to anyone.”
This incident serves as a stark reminder of the potential dangers lurking in seemingly mundane situations, highlighting the need for vigilance and community safety measures.
Watch a local news report about the incident below:
Let us know what you think, please share your thoughts in the comments below.

Old Man
October 27, 2024 at 11:57 am
Shawntae Hall, black, of course.
Don
October 27, 2024 at 1:25 pm
What a shame. These animals need a beat down.
paul
October 27, 2024 at 4:14 pm
It’s new dork, where it’s illegal to have a gun to protect yourself! Remember, when seconds count, don’t count on police! Just how long is the rap sheet on those pieces of shit? Leaving criminals in prison, is how they are supposed to prevent recidivism, not kiss their ass and set them free to prey on innocent people! The judge will just set them free again, after some A-hole lawyer pleas down the case and tells everyone they are just misunderstood! If it had been the other way around it would have been a racist crime, when does the white man get to call a racial crime?